Is it safe to keep the old furnace running while you decide?
Usually, yes. A furnace that is noisy, cycles often or struggles on the coldest nights can normally keep heating the house while you get a price for a replacement. In the meantime, keep the filter clean, keep the supply and return grilles clear of furniture, and make sure the plastic vent pipes on the outside wall are not covered by snow.
The exception is a cracked heat exchanger. The heat exchanger keeps the flame and its exhaust separate from the air blown through your rooms, and a crack can let combustion gases, including carbon monoxide, into that air. If a technician finds one, the furnace is shut off and you are shown why. Carbon monoxide alarms matter for the same reason. The Ontario Fire Code requires a working alarm next to each sleeping area of a home with a fuel-burning appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage. If an alarm sounds, take everyone outside and call the fire department from there.
If the furnace has stopped completely, begin with furnace repair. Plenty of no-heat problems are fixed by replacing a single part.
When does replacement make more sense than another repair?
The signs tend to build up slowly. The furnace has needed several repairs over the last few seasons, a major part such as the heat exchanger or a motor has failed on an older unit, some rooms have never been comfortable, or the equipment is simply the original that came with the house. In West Ridge, where homes were built from 1998 onward, this is now the usual question, because much of the builder-installed equipment is reaching the end of its service life.
Where a repair is still possible, you get both prices in writing, the repair and the replacement, so you can compare them side by side. If the repair is the sensible choice, you are told that plainly.
How is the right furnace size worked out?
The label on the old furnace tells you what someone chose years ago, not how much heat the house loses today. A furnace that is too large for the house heats in short bursts, wears faster and leaves cold corners. One that is too small runs without stopping on a cold night.
Sizing starts with the house: the rooms, the windows, the insulation that can be seen, and the way the home sits. Then come the ducts, because a furnace can only deliver as much air as the ducts will carry. In wartime and early post-war houses, like those on Argyle and Albany streets near Westmount Drive, the ductwork is often small and sparse, with weak airflow to the upper half-storey. A bigger furnace will not fix that, though a change to the duct runs or the return air sometimes will. The guide on what size furnace your house needs explains this in more detail.
Much of Orillia is older housing. The 2021 Census counted 14,425 occupied private dwellings in the city, of which 4,510 were built in 1960 or before and another 3,855 between 1961 and 1980. That is why the duct system gets as much attention as the furnace itself.
What happens to the chimney and the vent pipes?
Orillia's oldest homes, such as the Queen Anne houses on Mary Street and Mississaga Street West, the Art Deco house on Laclie Street and homes dating from around 1875, were built for stoves and coal. Many later had hot-water radiators or ducts added. In these houses a technician often finds an old masonry chimney that needs a liner before a modern furnace can be installed, and duct runs that are too small for the job. If the house has no ductwork at all, you will be told what is practical rather than sold a furnace that does not suit it.
Houses from the wartime and mid-1950s era usually started with a coal or oil furnace and were later converted to gas. The chimney typically needs a liner when the furnace is replaced, and sometimes an old oil tank has been left behind in the basement. If there is one, the technician will point it out and explain what it means for the job.
A high-efficiency furnace vents through plastic pipe out the side wall instead of the chimney. If a gas water heater is then left alone in the chimney, it may not draft properly, which is another reason the venting is explained before you approve a price. The position of the side-wall pipes matters too. Environment Canada's snow squall watches for the Barrie, Orillia and Midland region describe strong northwest winds and blowing snow, and drifts can cover a low vent. A buried vent makes the furnace shut itself off for safety, so the pipes are placed with snow in mind.
How does the installation itself go?
First a technician visits, looks at the house, the ducts, the chimney and the gas line, and talks through the options with you. You then get a written price, and nothing is started until you have approved it. Work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians, and in Ontario a gas furnace must be installed by a contractor registered with the Technical Standards and Safety Authority, under Ontario Regulation 212/01. The installation follows the CSA B149.1 Natural Gas and Propane Installation Code.
Within the city, natural gas comes from Enbridge Gas. If your home runs on propane, mention it when you get in touch, because the furnace is set up for the fuel it will burn.
On installation day, the old furnace is disconnected and removed, the new one is set in place and connected to the gas, venting, condensate drain and thermostat, and then it is started and tested. Before the technician leaves, you are shown where the filter goes and how to change it. Keep the paperwork. Many manufacturers ask for the furnace to be registered within a set period and serviced regularly to keep their warranty valid, and a yearly tune-up helps with that.
Should you look at rebates or a heat pump before you choose?
It is worth a look. The City of Orillia says rebate and incentive programs are available for energy-efficient upgrades, and it points homeowners to Save on Energy, Enbridge and Natural Resources Canada's directory of energy efficiency programs. Programs change, so check what is currently offered before you sign anything. The guide to heating and cooling rebates in Ontario shows where to look.
Some homeowners replacing a furnace also consider a cold-climate heat pump, or a hybrid system that pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. If that interests you, the heat pumps page explains how it works, and both options can be priced side by side. When you are ready, ask for a written price.
